Cake Eyeballs Recipe

If you’re looking for a fun, festive, and downright irresistible treat, this Cake Eyeballs Recipe is absolutely the way to go. I first made these for a Halloween party, and everyone couldn’t stop talking about how delightfully creepy — and delicious — they were. Whether you’re hosting a spooky get-together or just want a quirky dessert that will wow your friends and family, these eyeball-shaped cake balls deliver on cuteness and flavor. Stick around, because I’m sharing all my tips to make sure yours come out just perfect!

this …

Ingredients You’ll Need

These ingredients come together amazingly well, giving you moist cake bites coated with smooth, colorful candy that holds fun decorations perfectly. Pro tip: pick a cake flavor and frosting you personally love — it really shows through in the final taste!

• Cake mix: Choose your favorite flavor; I like chocolate or funfetti to keep things festive.
• Prepared frosting: This helps bind the cake crumbs; cream cheese frosting adds a nice tang if you want a twist.
• Candy melts: Pick a variety of colors – Wilton brand works great for smooth coating and vibrant hues.
• Decorations: Candy eyeballs, sprinkles, Twizzlers — go wild and get creative! I love using jumbo sprinkles for texture.

Variations

I love how customizable this Cake Eyeballs Recipe is! You can easily change up colors, decorations, or even cake flavors to match whatever vibe you’re going for — and it’s always a hit.

• Chocolate Lovers’ Variation: Use chocolate fudge cake mix and chocolate frosting for a rich, decadent bite.
• Vegan Option: Try a dairy-free cake mix and frosting, and vegan candy melts so everyone can enjoy them.
• Spooky Glow: Add edible glitter or use glow-in-the-dark sprinkles for a fun Halloween party trick I discovered recently.

How to Make Cake Eyeballs Recipe

Step 1: Bake Your Cake and Let It Cool

Follow the package directions for your cake mix and bake in a greased 13×9-inch pan. Cooling is key here — let it cool completely on a wire rack before moving on, or your cake balls will be soggy and hard to shape. I usually bake mine in the morning so by afternoon, it’s perfectly cooled and ready.

Step 2: Crumble and Mix with Frosting

Crumble the cooled cake into a large bowl, then add your frosting. I found that starting with a cup of frosting and adding more if needed helps get the perfect consistency — you want it moist enough to hold shape, but not gooey. Mix well so everything binds together nicely.

Step 3: Shape into Balls and Chill

Roll the mixture into 1 ½-inch balls (I use a small cookie scoop to get consistent sizes) and place them on baking sheets. Chill these in your freezer for at least 2 hours or in the fridge for around 3—this gives them the firmness needed to dip without falling apart. Patience here makes all the difference!

Step 4: Melt Candy and Dip

Melt your candy melts in the microwave carefully — I usually do 30 seconds at a time, stirring in between to avoid burning. Once smooth, dip each chilled cake ball, allowing excess coating to drip off. Place them back on the sheets and get ready to decorate.

Step 5: Decorate and Let Set

This is the fun part! Use candy eyeballs, sprinkles, or whatever decorations you love. I like adding a few drops of colored candy melt to make veins or spooky effects. Let the cake eyeballs stand at room temperature until the coating fully sets — this usually takes about 30 minutes to an hour.

How to Serve Cake Eyeballs Recipe

Garnishes

I tend to stick with candy eyeballs as the star garnish because they nail the spooky-but-cute factor. Adding a touch of colored sugar or edible glitter gives a fun sparkle, and jumbo sprinkles add a bit of crunch. These simple touches really bring the eyeballs to life for me.

Side Dishes

Pair these cake eyeballs with a cool drink like spiced cider or a fun punch to balance the sweetness. For a Halloween party, a platter of mixed chocolates and candy corn makes for a festive spread. Kids especially love a little “creepy candy” vibe!

Creative Ways to Present

I once arranged mine on a tray that looked like a spider web using black licorice as the lines — it was such a hit! You could also stick each eyeball on a colorful lollipop stick for a Halloween eyeball “pop.” Presentation makes these even more fun to serve and share.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Store cake eyeballs in an airtight container in the fridge. They’ve stayed fresh for about a week in my experience, and the coating keeps them from drying out. Just make sure they’re not squished — I like using a rigid container to protect their cute decorations.

Freezing

If you want to prep early, these freeze beautifully! I wrap each cake eyeball individually in plastic wrap, then keep them in a freezer-safe container. When thawed gently in the fridge, they retain their shape and flavor perfectly.

Reheating

Since these are best served chilled, reheating isn’t necessary — just bring frozen eyeballs to the fridge overnight to thaw. If you want them slightly softer, let them sit at room temp for 15-20 minutes. They’ll still be delicious and hold their fun shape!

FAQs

Final Thoughts

I absolutely love how this Cake Eyeballs Recipe turns out every single time — the combination of moist cake, creamy frosting, and that vibrant candy coating is just unbeatable. When I first tried this, I was worried the eyeballs would be tricky, but with a bit of patience and my pro tips, you’ll find it’s super fun and totally doable. My family goes crazy for these, especially when I whip them out at Halloween or birthday parties. Trust me, they’re a crowd-pleaser and such a conversation starter. So grab your favorite cake mix and candy melts, and let’s get baking some spooky, scrumptious eyeballs!

Print